Steps Every Homeowner Should Take Before Filing a Property Tax Appeal

A Simple Checklist to Get Prepared

Filing a property tax appeal in Cook County can feel intimidating if you’ve never done it before. But with the right preparation, you can improve your chances of success and potentially save hundreds or even thousands of dollars on your annual tax bill.

The appeal process isn’t about fighting taxes in general—it’s about making sure your property is assessed fairly compared to similar homes in your area. To do that, you’ll need to be organized and ready with evidence before you file. Below is a simple checklist that every homeowner should complete before submitting an appeal.

---

1. Review Your Property Assessment

Your first step is to visit the Cook County Assessor’s Office website and pull up your property information using your Property Index Number (PIN). This record lists details about your home, such as:

• Square footage
  
• Number of bedrooms and bathrooms
  
• Lot size
  
• Building type and construction details
  
• Features like a finished basement or garage
  

Carefully review these details. If something is wrong—such as the wrong lot size or wrong construction type—you may already have grounds for an appeal.

---

2. Understand Your Filing Deadline

Appeals in Cook County are only open during certain periods. Each township has a specific filing window when property owners can submit appeals. Missing your deadline means waiting until the next tax year.

Check the Assessor’s Office website for the calendar of filing dates. If you decide to take your case further, you can also appeal to the Cook County Board of Review, which has its own separate deadlines. Staying aware of these timelines ensures you don’t lose your chance to challenge your assessment.

---

3. Gather Comparable Properties (“Comps”)

One of the strongest ways to show your assessment is too high is by using comparable properties. These are homes similar to yours in:

• Size
  
• Age
  
• Style
  
• Location
  

Look for comps that are assessed at lower values or that have sold recently for less than your estimated market value. For example, if your three-bedroom home is valued at $400,000 but nearly identical homes nearby are assessed at $350,000, that’s strong evidence of an error.

Both the Assessor’s Office and the Board of Review allow homeowners to submit comparable property information as part of an appeal.

---

4. Collect Evidence of Property Condition

Another important factor is the actual condition of your property. Assessments generally assume properties are in average condition. But if your home needs major repairs, its market value may be lower.

Gather evidence such as:

• Photos of needed repairs (roof damage, foundation cracks, outdated systems)
  
• Contractor estimates for repair costs
  
• Inspection reports showing condition issues
  

This type of documentation shows that your property is not worth as much as the Assessor’s Office believes. Though note, an appraisal would likely be beneficial in this situation.

---

5. Check for Uniformity

Uniformity is the principle that similar properties should be assessed similarly. Sometimes, two nearly identical homes on the same block are valued very differently.

To check for uniformity issues, look at assessments of neighboring homes with the same style and square footage. If your property is assessed significantly higher, that’s a clear sign of inequity.

---

6. Decide How You’ll File

In Cook County, you can file a property tax appeal with either the Assessor’s Office or the Board of Review, or even both. Each has its own process and deadlines:

• Assessor’s Office
  
  • File online using the SmartFile system (most common option).
    
  • This is typically the first step for most homeowners.
    
  • Decisions are based on the evidence you submit—no hearings are held at this stage.
    
• Board of Review
  
  • If you are not satisfied with the Assessor’s decision or the Assessor’s assessed valuation, you can appeal here.
    
  • File online through the Board’s own SmartFile portal.
    
  • You may also request a hearing during your filing if you want to present your case in person.
    

Be sure to carefully follow the deadlines for each office, as they are separate and must be met to protect your rights.

---

7. Organize Your Appeal Packet

Before you submit, make sure your evidence is clear and organized. A strong appeal packet may include:

• Corrected property record information
  
• Comparable property assessments or sales data
  
• Photos and estimates for major repairs (with an appraisal)
  
• A short written explanation tying everything together
  

The goal is to make it as easy as possible for the reviewer to understand why your assessment should be reduced.

---

8. Consider Professional Help

While you can file an appeal on your own, many homeowners choose to work with a professional. An experienced Cook County property tax Attorney can help you gather evidence, prepare your case, and present it in the most effective way. Because property tax appeals can be technical, having someone who understands the system often makes a big difference.

---

9. Keep Records for the Future

Even if you win your appeal this year, assessments are updated regularly in Cook County. Keep copies of all the evidence you submitted and the final decision. This makes it easier to file again in the future if needed.

---

Final Thoughts

Filing a property tax appeal isn’t about avoiding taxes—it’s about fairness. If your assessment is higher than it should be, you could be paying more than your fair share. By reviewing your property record, gathering comps, documenting repairs, and submitting your appeal on time, you give yourself the best chance of success.

For many homeowners, this process can feel overwhelming. But by following this checklist step by step, you’ll be well prepared to challenge an inaccurate assessment and potentially lower your property tax bill.